Saturday, November 6, 2010

Why is Online Learning More Challenging?

 I have been looking at the MBT online platform in terms of BT#1, 2, and 3.  Without any tangible, visible, audible and smell able physical characteristics- which normally contribute to the students’ emotional reaction and standing relative to the learning at hand, the way the platform and the professors establish, sustain, and nurture the emotional climate looms even larger.  Furthermore, without the routines and rituals, face to face discussions and banter, and physical structures to complement and support the student learning, the way the course is structured, i.e., the  learning design has to be considered with evn great care, for it must take into account all those “missing factors and features.”
It goes without saying, designing an online learning course presents new challenges for everyone, students and teachers and professors alike. Without the eye contact, handshakes, and face to face personal connections, the emotional climate has to be established in other ways.  I believe that we need to think about how we can make online learning more personal and build more connections because we don’t have the usual scaffolding, which in fact, we are neurophysiologically wired to depend upon when it comes to learning. (How ironic is that?)
Despite the inherent difficulties and challenges presented by simply looking at BT#1, 2, &3, I believe online learning has great potential and it is the wave of the future, we need to learn to ride.
I am a long time devotee of Parker Palmer. I have had the honor of hearing him speak, I have read his books, attended numerous retreats, and led book clubs with my faculty around his work. It is apropos that Sharon Delgado, our teacher mentor in this course, asked me if I was familiar with his work because his work can help us analyze what works and what needs to happen for an online learning platform to be successful.  
I believe that we need to delve deeper when considering the components of creating an emotional climate for an online professional learning community such as the MBT cohort. As Parker Palmer presents in The Courage to Teach, we must ask ourselves “who is the self that teaches?”  And I would add, “Who is the self that learns?”  As Parker explains , we are accustomed to asking the what, how, and why questions, what subject will we teach, how will we do it (what methods and techniques), and why or for what purpose and to what end  do we aspire to teach- but how often do educational institutions look deep into the inner landscape of the teaching self?
For me the inner landscape of teaching (and learning) is directly related to the emotional climate, which in turn, is directly related to how I feel connected to myself and what I am learning and to whom I am connected with in the learning process.
It has been an adjustment for me to cope with the lack of personal connection with and feedback from the professors. My last graduate school experience was quite the opposite; however, it was not online. There was a time in my life when I reveled in self- directed, independent studies. I remember I took calculus as an independent study and I loved it because I was convinced that no one had ever taught me any math- it was just a matter of my giving myself enough time to make sense of it on my own.
It is interesting how we can change over the course of our lives as students and learners and how we must constantly push ourselves to be honest about our own vulnerabilities.  Upon self reflection, I realize now that on some level I was feeling the need for a “teacher,” a professor, a mentor in learning when I signed up for the MBT certificate.  While I have been disappointed by the lack of personal connection with the professors, I have been floored by the support of my cyber mates. Has anyone ever experienced or seen so many “strangers” so willing and able and dedicated to working collaboratively and to giving one another positive affirmations? The energy and camaraderie of the teams and the affirmative tone of the responses in the threads has created something palpable: we have created a huge part of the emotional climate we need. However, I still feel critical and disappointed that the professors are not a part of this and have remained distant. I have been ever thankful for Sharon’s role as a teacher mentor and keenly attune to her ability to reveal her core being. It is clear to me that Sharon is a teacher who brings her whole self to the job.  I want to venture to ask the professors to think about what they could do differently to bring more of themselves to this learning community and to think about how they could become more personally involved and make more connections with us. I think given the online platform- their responsibilities along these lines are actually greater than in the traditional format.
We are wired to connect and for connection. During the orientation stage of this course, I think Jean Imbriale did a wonderful job getting us all to know one another as well as getting us to take risks as students in terms of having us use Web 2.0 tools. We told our stories, at least part of our stories.  I think the subsequent formation of teams was a great move as well because it has allowed us to narrow our focus and efforts to connect to a more manageable number of people.  As the course has unfolded, my team has grown closer and more connected, in part because we had to accept that we were not receiving much feedback from the professors.
 I think the professors could have introduced themselves using the very same Web 2.0 tools we used. I think the professors could ask us to share more of ourselves and our professional lives with the first two BT stages. We could be asked to continue to tell more of our stories (granted many have on the threads that have evolved.)  Stories help connect people and they help us make meaning. The professors could share more of their stories. I would love to hear Mariale talk about her work as a principal, how she transformed that school. We have only been shown short clips of the teachers describing their beliefs- those have been wonderful but if we are to become a part of doing that type of work in our schools we need the rest of story. How did those teachers change their teaching? How did Mariale create a new vision and inspire her faculty? We have heard her voice on her videos but it has not been reflective of her personal trials and tribulations.(Granted this might Not be her style or inclination- I am just trying to brainstorm and throw out ideas)
Back to the assignments on BT #1 and 2, we could have been asked to photograph and film the physical spaces we work in and apply our assessment tools to our own lives as teachers. We could have been asked to have our students evaluate the emotional climate, which in turn would force us to self reflect.  I think the blogs add an important dimension to our learning “space” but perhaps we could be teamed up in some way so that we were reading a couple of our cyber mates’ blogs and responding since the professors don’t seem to have time.
The motive behind the requirement that we respond to one another’s posts  is sound but as a student the platform is unwieldy.  There end up being too many posts and too many at the end of each week. I haven’t been able to read them all. I know I am missing good thought provoking material.  Perhaps we could be partnered to respond (rotate partners) or put in triads. In other words, I think the structure needs to be evaluated so we could get more out of it.
Overall the unfolding of the assignments has been challenging for me. I have whined more than I ever have as a student about the workload- so many simultaneous assignments, I have moaned.  My friends, who know me well, say to me- if you are whining, how is anyone keeping up? In other words, I like to work hard. I expect to work hard but I think the structure of this course could be revamped to maximize our learning. Less could be more. We don’t need two team projects a week and two long-term assignments and two threads to follow and more and more and more.  The variety of the assignments has been wonderful and I have enjoyed the fact that the professors have balanced the text reading with videos, clips, and shorter articles but I think the unfolding of the activities and the overlapping of assignments need to be reconsidered. The simultaneity of assignments is overwhelming.
I obviously have never designed or taught an online course and one reason I signed up for this online course was so that I could experience something new. By accident when I went to register for the spring courses, I saw that Neurophysiology of Learning Differences is being taught by Dr. Denckla online and on Wednesday evenings from 4:30 to 6:30. Ahh, I let out a sign of yearning to attend that once a week lecture and to have the rest of the week to process it and work on whatever assignments I had been given. I imagined it would be so much easier than spending hours every night plucking through all those responses and wading through all the assignments I have with my team and on my own in this online scenario.
 I know that I am deluding myself. Good learning experiences always require hard work. But honestly, I cannot sustain the amount of time I have been spending thus far for the next year and a half. My job at my school is demanding and I am dedicated to giving it as much of myself as I can.  I sincerely hope that different professors will structure their courses differently in subsequent semesters. I also hope that we aren’t always required to spend so much time working collaboratively. As much as I can say, it is through the collaborative work that I have learned the most so far, I think I need some ebb and flow in order to give that team work my all, when it comes around. I personally need more time for self-reflection and more time to apply what I am learning to my own professional setting.
 I believe Parker Palmer has a lot to teach us and I would like to integrate what I am learning in this course to my own “inner landscape.”  I want to reflect more on how an online platform can not only nurture deeper connections amongst learners but also foster the inner growth of teachers themselves as learners. And in this setting and from this experience, I want to ask myself more questions about how we can better work together to create an emotional climate that is sustainable- one that refuels us and inspires us forward to learn even more. I am feeling depleted now. I trust I will regain my strength. My ultimate learning goal is to be able to apply all that I am learning in deep ways in the multiple dimensions of my life and I know that will take me years. Learning is a process and these weeks are just a small part of the whole.  
The whole whose parts I don’t even know. That whole that is always evolving, growing and changing.



3 comments:

Victoria Raskin (mariposas) said...

Merry: You wrote of my heart and my mind and my delight and frustration of this learning curve and this course. Thank you for putting this so profoundly in prose that is from the heart. I agree with EVERYTHING you are saying and I too wonder about my ability to sustain my level of participation. I also have never been such a GMC (Groaner, Moaner and Complainer-- well maybe when I had to take Graduate level Statistics.Thank you for voicing this!
Best,
Victoria R

Anonymous said...

Hi Merry,

Like you I have had wonderful experiences with traditional learning paradigms.

As you know, I just completed the face to face version of this course in August.
The twenty-five of us read the same books, saw & heard the real Mariale not the virtual one, and worked in teams cooperatively to process the knowledge and created the same Posner chapter presentations. As teams we also worked together on the BTT unit model.

It was very, very intense for us also.

At the end of the course Mariale asked for feedback. One item we requested was to make the BTT unit an individual assignment. We felt that we were working at different grade levels and different subjects. We really wanted the opportunity to relate the unit to our own area of expertise. When I read the syllabus for this course I was glad to see that Mariale had made that change.

As I have been noting similarities between the two versions of the class, I have also been struck by the differences. The F2F class was exactly as you described in your journal entry. We joked, ate meals together, formed friendships that we hope are lasting. In fact a group of us have continued to meet monthly because want to remain contacted to “like-minded” teachers who want their practice to be informed by neuroscience.

The online class, of course, can only offer virtual versions of the above.

I have taken exactly one online course. Some teachers at my school are right now in the middle of one offered by another university. In that course (and the one I took) there is no actual interaction with the instructor. Students have a six month window to “submit” their assignments which will be read and graded by some anonymous instructors at a still later date. The online “discussion” between students is unmonitored. Personally I really disliked this method.

It’s amazing to me, but a couple my colleagues are just fine with the course they are taking. They say they can work at their convenience and the deadlines are great because, hey, they have six months after the course “ends” to get the assignments in.
End pt 1 of comment

Anonymous said...

So…there are a great variety of online courses and different points of view about these courses. I hated the type of course described in the last paragraph. My younger colleagues think that it is cool and convenient.

When I was interviewed for the position of Teacher-mentor the first thing I said to Mariale was that I hoped somehow we could virtually simulate the learning community the F2F course was. She, Luke, and Emma almost in unison said, “You’ve got it! That’s our goal”

In the F2F class we had one instructor – Dr. Hardiman herself. To foster an online learning community Mariale bought on three extra people. We four (Mariale, Luke, Emma, and me) are working really, really hard to make this online experience the best it can be.

At the university Mariale, Luke, and Emma along with the tech team are in the process of building this online course. Personally I think so far they have provided you with outstanding materials and really awesome Web 2.0 experiences.

In many ways I am sure my fellow F2F students would be jealous of you and your classmates. The lectures and all the presentation experiences are right at your fingertips for you to access at any time as often as you might like. You can probably download them so you’ll have them forever. (We didn’t think about video-taping Mariale.) Plus we had none of the Web 2.0 experiences.

To encourage the building of an online learning community and foster friendships, Mariale built in many opportunities for team work. I would say she was successful here. From my observations you and your team mates really are friends as well as fellow students. I didn’t think it would be possible for this to happen so quickly online, but it has.

She bought me on board to be the Teacher-mentor. My charge is to provide you with lots of feedback. I’m doing the best I can. Remember I am a full time teacher, too.

Is the course perfect? No, of course it’s not. It still is a work in progress. I agree that maybe there are too many group assignments. I can assure you that the idea was to foster higher level processing and to build the online community.

To support the notion of higher level processing I offer this quote:
“Writing is thinking made tangible, thinking that can be examined because it is on the page and not in the head, invisible, floating around. Writing is thinking that can be stopped and tinkered with. It is a way of holding thought still long enough to examine its structures, its possibilities, its flaws. The road to a clearer understanding is travelled on paper. (Could we now change that to “travelled online”) It is through an attempt to find words for ourselves in which to express related ideas that we often discover what we think.” Gage, J. (1986).

Think about all the writing you are doing. In the F2F class we spoke and the words just fluttered into the air – gone in an instant. Online not only do you process your words at higher levels, but you also can go back a reread what you wrote and you can reread the words of your colleagues. All we had in F2F was our memories.

Gage wrote this passage ten years before the invention of the World Wide Web and the bridging of neuroscience to education. Imagine what he would have to say about the ability of Web 2.0 to inspire higher level thinking - which we might now refer to as the building of millions of new neural synaptic connections.

I see in the HOTS activity that most of the teams used the “Question” section to offer their ideas for improvement. I have absolutely no doubt that Mariale will be as open to the suggestions of this class as she was to us when it comes to up-dating this course.

Very best regards,
Sharon

Post a Comment