Monday, December 13, 2010

Neuroscience: Simultaneously Uncovering Answers and Discovering New Questions

         
 I am looking forward to reviewing all we have covered this fall before we start our coursework up again in January. The amount of time I had to spend on group work for this course severely reduced the time I had available for reflection.  As an experienced adult learner, I know I need  time to reframe, re-visualize, and summarize new material if I am to retain any of it, and now I know there is neuroscientific data to support my experience. I sincerely hope that next semester the professors will build in the time learners need, and consider supporting structures for that reflective and summarizing time, instead of assigning multiple overlapping group assignments.
I look forward to learning more about:
·         neural mechanisms for creativity
·         early attention training
·         neural mechanisms related to motivation
·         the development of executive function
·         Neurophysiological basis of our sense of self-and consciousness
·         Effect of screen-time and attempts at multitasking  
·         Deeper consideration of how we  communicate and develop relationships online
·         Sustainable teaching- refuel ourselves as lifelong learners and
·         Mirror neurons
·          learning design
·          Marzano’s dimensions of learning
·         best practices for applying what we already know

I keep thinking about the Learning and the Brain Conference I attended in Boston last month. It helped crystallize what I have been learning about brain-based targeted teaching. What struck me most about the Conference was the repeated call for neuroscientists, psychologists and educators to work collaboratively.  As an educator, I realized how important it is for teachers to ask questions about all the brain processes involved in learning- emotion, attention, and social processing.  I was particularly impressed  by Mary Helen Immordino-Yang . She seemed to touch on everything I have been interested in for years and she related it all to neuroscience!
               
After hearing her speak I had hope that educational institutions could someday be transformed. She is working on a project that looks at the neurobiology and psychology of admiration and compassion and  it draws on neuroscience, psychology, sociology, and cultural influences. She was inspiring both in her ability to articulate her findings and to examine her findings to raise additional interesting questions.  I found her discussion around how we develop a sense of ourselves particularly fascinating and how that sense is related to internal reflection, even more riveting.
I was thrilled to come home and discover there are Youtube videos of her speaking and many of her papers are easily accessible online. Now I will have time to read them all, watch her videos, and delve deeper. There was so much to talk about around her work- not only how our minds and body work together when we learn but how technology and some urban environments today are keeping young adults from developing those internal reflection and self-aware wiring in their brains and what that means in terms of our world, which so depends on compassion and feeling connected. Given the problems in our world, it will take working together across cultures, national boundaries and interests to tackle the problems we have globally.  As educators, we need to think deeply about how we nurture  reflective, meditative, and spiritual time to foster the healthy development of a sense of self. Surely, this must be one of the most important 21st century skills.  In our own lives as teachers, we need to know how to sustain ourselves and our teaching work as well.  How do we stay connected to ourselves , our families, our communities and develop a sense of purpose as a member of a global interdependent world?
         Neuroscience is uncovering as many answers as it is new questions. I feel as if I am riding the same wave. While I have learned a great deal this fall, I have more questions than ever and I know I need time just to digest the feast we have had of content. One thing is for certain: I will continue to use the brain-based teaching model as a framework for my teaching and I look forward to sharing it with my colleagues at school.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

Why is Online Learning More Challenging?

 I have been looking at the MBT online platform in terms of BT#1, 2, and 3.  Without any tangible, visible, audible and smell able physical characteristics- which normally contribute to the students’ emotional reaction and standing relative to the learning at hand, the way the platform and the professors establish, sustain, and nurture the emotional climate looms even larger.  Furthermore, without the routines and rituals, face to face discussions and banter, and physical structures to complement and support the student learning, the way the course is structured, i.e., the  learning design has to be considered with evn great care, for it must take into account all those “missing factors and features.”
It goes without saying, designing an online learning course presents new challenges for everyone, students and teachers and professors alike. Without the eye contact, handshakes, and face to face personal connections, the emotional climate has to be established in other ways.  I believe that we need to think about how we can make online learning more personal and build more connections because we don’t have the usual scaffolding, which in fact, we are neurophysiologically wired to depend upon when it comes to learning. (How ironic is that?)
Despite the inherent difficulties and challenges presented by simply looking at BT#1, 2, &3, I believe online learning has great potential and it is the wave of the future, we need to learn to ride.
I am a long time devotee of Parker Palmer. I have had the honor of hearing him speak, I have read his books, attended numerous retreats, and led book clubs with my faculty around his work. It is apropos that Sharon Delgado, our teacher mentor in this course, asked me if I was familiar with his work because his work can help us analyze what works and what needs to happen for an online learning platform to be successful.  
I believe that we need to delve deeper when considering the components of creating an emotional climate for an online professional learning community such as the MBT cohort. As Parker Palmer presents in The Courage to Teach, we must ask ourselves “who is the self that teaches?”  And I would add, “Who is the self that learns?”  As Parker explains , we are accustomed to asking the what, how, and why questions, what subject will we teach, how will we do it (what methods and techniques), and why or for what purpose and to what end  do we aspire to teach- but how often do educational institutions look deep into the inner landscape of the teaching self?
For me the inner landscape of teaching (and learning) is directly related to the emotional climate, which in turn, is directly related to how I feel connected to myself and what I am learning and to whom I am connected with in the learning process.
It has been an adjustment for me to cope with the lack of personal connection with and feedback from the professors. My last graduate school experience was quite the opposite; however, it was not online. There was a time in my life when I reveled in self- directed, independent studies. I remember I took calculus as an independent study and I loved it because I was convinced that no one had ever taught me any math- it was just a matter of my giving myself enough time to make sense of it on my own.
It is interesting how we can change over the course of our lives as students and learners and how we must constantly push ourselves to be honest about our own vulnerabilities.  Upon self reflection, I realize now that on some level I was feeling the need for a “teacher,” a professor, a mentor in learning when I signed up for the MBT certificate.  While I have been disappointed by the lack of personal connection with the professors, I have been floored by the support of my cyber mates. Has anyone ever experienced or seen so many “strangers” so willing and able and dedicated to working collaboratively and to giving one another positive affirmations? The energy and camaraderie of the teams and the affirmative tone of the responses in the threads has created something palpable: we have created a huge part of the emotional climate we need. However, I still feel critical and disappointed that the professors are not a part of this and have remained distant. I have been ever thankful for Sharon’s role as a teacher mentor and keenly attune to her ability to reveal her core being. It is clear to me that Sharon is a teacher who brings her whole self to the job.  I want to venture to ask the professors to think about what they could do differently to bring more of themselves to this learning community and to think about how they could become more personally involved and make more connections with us. I think given the online platform- their responsibilities along these lines are actually greater than in the traditional format.
We are wired to connect and for connection. During the orientation stage of this course, I think Jean Imbriale did a wonderful job getting us all to know one another as well as getting us to take risks as students in terms of having us use Web 2.0 tools. We told our stories, at least part of our stories.  I think the subsequent formation of teams was a great move as well because it has allowed us to narrow our focus and efforts to connect to a more manageable number of people.  As the course has unfolded, my team has grown closer and more connected, in part because we had to accept that we were not receiving much feedback from the professors.
 I think the professors could have introduced themselves using the very same Web 2.0 tools we used. I think the professors could ask us to share more of ourselves and our professional lives with the first two BT stages. We could be asked to continue to tell more of our stories (granted many have on the threads that have evolved.)  Stories help connect people and they help us make meaning. The professors could share more of their stories. I would love to hear Mariale talk about her work as a principal, how she transformed that school. We have only been shown short clips of the teachers describing their beliefs- those have been wonderful but if we are to become a part of doing that type of work in our schools we need the rest of story. How did those teachers change their teaching? How did Mariale create a new vision and inspire her faculty? We have heard her voice on her videos but it has not been reflective of her personal trials and tribulations.(Granted this might Not be her style or inclination- I am just trying to brainstorm and throw out ideas)
Back to the assignments on BT #1 and 2, we could have been asked to photograph and film the physical spaces we work in and apply our assessment tools to our own lives as teachers. We could have been asked to have our students evaluate the emotional climate, which in turn would force us to self reflect.  I think the blogs add an important dimension to our learning “space” but perhaps we could be teamed up in some way so that we were reading a couple of our cyber mates’ blogs and responding since the professors don’t seem to have time.
The motive behind the requirement that we respond to one another’s posts  is sound but as a student the platform is unwieldy.  There end up being too many posts and too many at the end of each week. I haven’t been able to read them all. I know I am missing good thought provoking material.  Perhaps we could be partnered to respond (rotate partners) or put in triads. In other words, I think the structure needs to be evaluated so we could get more out of it.
Overall the unfolding of the assignments has been challenging for me. I have whined more than I ever have as a student about the workload- so many simultaneous assignments, I have moaned.  My friends, who know me well, say to me- if you are whining, how is anyone keeping up? In other words, I like to work hard. I expect to work hard but I think the structure of this course could be revamped to maximize our learning. Less could be more. We don’t need two team projects a week and two long-term assignments and two threads to follow and more and more and more.  The variety of the assignments has been wonderful and I have enjoyed the fact that the professors have balanced the text reading with videos, clips, and shorter articles but I think the unfolding of the activities and the overlapping of assignments need to be reconsidered. The simultaneity of assignments is overwhelming.
I obviously have never designed or taught an online course and one reason I signed up for this online course was so that I could experience something new. By accident when I went to register for the spring courses, I saw that Neurophysiology of Learning Differences is being taught by Dr. Denckla online and on Wednesday evenings from 4:30 to 6:30. Ahh, I let out a sign of yearning to attend that once a week lecture and to have the rest of the week to process it and work on whatever assignments I had been given. I imagined it would be so much easier than spending hours every night plucking through all those responses and wading through all the assignments I have with my team and on my own in this online scenario.
 I know that I am deluding myself. Good learning experiences always require hard work. But honestly, I cannot sustain the amount of time I have been spending thus far for the next year and a half. My job at my school is demanding and I am dedicated to giving it as much of myself as I can.  I sincerely hope that different professors will structure their courses differently in subsequent semesters. I also hope that we aren’t always required to spend so much time working collaboratively. As much as I can say, it is through the collaborative work that I have learned the most so far, I think I need some ebb and flow in order to give that team work my all, when it comes around. I personally need more time for self-reflection and more time to apply what I am learning to my own professional setting.
 I believe Parker Palmer has a lot to teach us and I would like to integrate what I am learning in this course to my own “inner landscape.”  I want to reflect more on how an online platform can not only nurture deeper connections amongst learners but also foster the inner growth of teachers themselves as learners. And in this setting and from this experience, I want to ask myself more questions about how we can better work together to create an emotional climate that is sustainable- one that refuels us and inspires us forward to learn even more. I am feeling depleted now. I trust I will regain my strength. My ultimate learning goal is to be able to apply all that I am learning in deep ways in the multiple dimensions of my life and I know that will take me years. Learning is a process and these weeks are just a small part of the whole.  
The whole whose parts I don’t even know. That whole that is always evolving, growing and changing.



Friday, October 22, 2010

Calling for New Neural Networks

No matter how sophisticated our neuroimaging techniques are and can become- in terms of viewing brain activity and the firing of neural networks while a person is performing given tasks.....we will most likely still assess that person’s learning by a different means- e.g., performance assessment or another application.  In other words, cognitive scientists and educators will need to continue to work together. It might be that neuroscientists can use imaging to locate specific areas of the brain and/or specific neural networks in action when a person is doing specific tasks but the momentum behind this effort is to obtain an even broader picture. When those neural networks are firing together, what does it mean in terms of what that individual can do and what are the connections or extensions of that learning? How do those firings or those neural networks relate or extend to higher-order thinking? And, even more important, can that individual apply that higher order thinking effectively to a worthy cause? (which takes this discussion beyond neuroscience and education)
It is exciting that certain mental processes have been linked to certain brain structures and we are gaining a better understanding of how people learn. This can help us design more effective instructional techniques. However, it seems what is happening at the cellular level in the brain will only be one piece of the marvel- when it comes to considering a functioning human being. How people learn is only part of the whole: what they experience: how they perceive their experiences: each unique individual has layers of stories as to who he or she is. Ultimately the world is a better place depending on what people do with that learning, their intelligence, attention, talents and genetic endowment in relation to other people, who are just as complex with their own unique “wiring” and experiences.
Cognitive genetics is a new field. Some day we might be able to understand differences between individuals in terms of intelligence and temperament in terms of variations in genes. However, I don’t want to imagine schools performing genetic tests to track students. Instead, I hope that in better understanding the relationship of genes and experience in shaping a students learning potential, schools can find ways to develop effective instructional techniques for all.
We are learning more about what happens in the brain as people look, listen, attend and remember. The best case scenario would be thinking that the more we know about the way the brain works as people learn, the more effective and efficient our teaching could become. However, I don’t think it will ever be that simple.  Humans are too complex. People are always subject to their experiences and we can never isolate one teaching strategy for example and verifiably say- it is what caused “the learning,” because there are so many factors involved in every individual and so many factors that influence learning. Overall health, emotions, psychology, socialization, family upbringing, culture, genetics....(the list goes on and on) all have an impact on learning.
So far our best approach is to think in terms of models, like the Brain-Targeted Teaching model, in order to be sure our school’s are maximizing the environment for learning so that learning can be positive for a wide range of students, because of their inherently wide range of temperaments, genetic endowments, intelligence, and powers of attention and all the other corroborating factors listed above.
Instead of working in isolated fields of study, genetic, cognitive and neuro-scientists, educational psychologists, and teacher researchers need to work together to synthesize their ideas and to ask new questions in order to redesign our schools so that they can be a place for learning for all students. At its best, schools are places for growth and they indeed have been where many have found their “calling” and discovered their passions- which in turn, set them on their life journey. But too many students report that school stifled their growth, their creativity, their very ability to have a vision for their future because it made them lose confidence in themselves and set them on a downward trajectory. This is the worst to face – but we must. And we must do something about it. It will take many great minds with a variety of expertise and special knowledge all firing (working) together.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Dimensions of Attention

“Attention involves specific networks of the brain that mature from infancy (see Chapter 3) well into childhood (see Chapter 4). However, attention also involves regulation of the activity of other networks, thus improving the prospects of acquiring an unlimited number of skills. Attentional networks interact with other brain systems to establish priorities in perception and action. This ability to regulate brain function makes attention relevant to all domains of learning. ….We also argue that increases in attentional  efficiency can influence progress in a wide range of school subjects (see Chapters 7, 8, and 9). In this sense, attention serves as a different kind of formal discipline that can influence the efficiency of operations of a wide range of cognitive and emotional networks.” (Posner & Rothbart text, page 16)

I have lifted this excerpt because it caught my total attention.
 Imagine the following school schedule: English, History, Science, Math, Attention!
The truth is- students have made Attention a subject for teachers. It keeps us humble and keeps us learning. We are constantly trying to get our students’ attention, clarify their focus, organize their thoughts etc. etc. No matter the subject- the students’ attentional  efficiency  defines the teachers  constraints-  gives them their work. And as a teacher- this experience can be as frustrating as getting water from stone or as wonderful as flying free as a bird.  
I am thinking back to the Overview of this text, Educating the Human Brain,  and remembering how the authors  stated that knowledge about the brain alone cannot provide a blueprint for how to educate.  However, information about brain development can assist us in our educational design. They made an analogy that resonated for me- i.e., Just as the landscape and materials affect the way engineers and architects design a bridge, the wiring of the brain should certainly affect the way we work as educators to design our schools and teach our students.
Generally, when I think about Attention, I think of it in terms way beyond the scope of the reading thus far. It is fascinating to learn how attentional networks  develop in infancy and through childhood but I keep thinking about how many adults I know who are still working on developing what I would call their “attentional” networks. Myself included.
If you ever have taken up painting or Tai Chi or still study piano, you know how hard you must work and concentrate and how slowly and steadily you can improve if you stick to it. I  also cannot think of the word attention without thinking about mindfulness and being present. In an alphabet of spiritual literacy, Attention is the first word on the list.
Pay attention. Stay awake. Totally alert. See with receptive eyes and discover a world of ceaseless wonders.
( from  Spiritual Literacy by Frederic and MaryAnn Brussat)
Being present, seeing beauty, making connections, being kind, cultivating the art of deep listening, falling in love over and over again, discovering and making meaning, remaining open, savoring questions, finding silence, making peace, cultivating wonder, imagining the invisible and unknown, accepting mystery-   ALL depend on  attention.
So “this ability to regulate brain function” makes attention more than relevant to all domains of learning---- Attention is sacred. It shapes our core as humans. It ultimately defines who we are and who we can become.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Week One -Rethinking and Rewiring Learning

I experienced a paradigm shift in my thinking watching Wesch’s “The Machine is Using Us” especially following it up with viewing his video  ”A  Vision of Students Today.”  I realized that seeing the World Wide Web only in terms of its content and an overwhelming mass of information, is somewhat like looking at the brain in terms of localized regions and billions of cells. It struck me that we can be connected via the Web the way the regions of the brain are connected by developing circuits in learning. The power of the Web isn’t in one particular area just as the “intelligence of the brain” is not localized. The marvel of both is in the creation of circuitry. In the case of the Web, we live in a time and have the technology to share ideas globally. If we work together, we can address global problems that are not being addressed by giving them localized attention. I think I experienced a shift in my thinking because I had this resurgence of hope after watching Wesch’s video- that people connecting to people can and will make all the difference (as they always have).
 I finally have a broader picture that gives the Web more meaning. For too long, I just saw it as a huge library of information- but it is so much more than that:  it’s a space where ideas and people with ideas can meet and the power of that is something to marvel.  I might have judgments about the time the younger generation spends social networking but networking is the foundation for solving the world’s problems. Who would have thought Wikipedia would surpass every encyclopedia I grew up with. Yes, we have to look at authorship in new ways, just as the video suggests- and more.  I can already see that a wonderful by-product  of taking this course on line has been expanding my appreciation of Web 2.0 tools and experiencing first hand working collaboratively with people I haven’t even ever met.
At first I was struck by how little interaction there was with the professors of the course. I was looking yesterday at all the responses of the students and noted that the professors had only responded to two students each, as if they were following our required number of responses themselves. This was eye-opening to me. I had assumed the traditional model of teaching, within which I had assumed the professors would respond to each and every one of us. Alas, I see now that we will all be our own professors- we carry this responsibility as a cohort of learners. And as a member of my team, I can already sense that we all feel this responsibility to one another.  Indeed, the response I received from one fellow student meant more to me than any response from the professor could have. And as much as I know the students in my class value and depend upon my responses to them and support of their work, I also know how much the opinion, support and recognition of their classmates means to them.
It is ironic that as a teacher I want my students to “take responsibility” for their learning and their stature as students, and yet as a learner myself, I am still learning how to grow into that role. I am daunted by the tasks at hand. Simply the sheer amount of reading is awesome. It takes me time to process the ideas because I need to find connections to what I already know for any of it to make sense. The brain-targeted teaching model makes sense because it resonates with so much of what I have known for years as a teacher about best practices and good teaching. And yet, I think most schools still fall short.           
Generally educational  institutions  are set up by content areas.  All too often students are taught in fragments and they must forge their own connections and develop their own contexts to make meaning.  As a younger student myself, growing up with the ideas of Marshall McLuhan, I remember wondering why school had divided the world into history, English, math and science. The shocking thing is- it is still that way! I think because of the Web- today’s younger generation can finally force that to change.
Neuroscience has progressed past phrenology but has education progressed? As Mariale Hardiman explained-- it might sound obvious to say learning happens in the brain, but the brain-based targeting teaching model had to be developed because a lot of teaching doesn’t result in learning. Does the entire structure of educational institutions have to be re-built or can the energy and power of the people-to-people and idea-to-idea interactions and connections reframe these environments?
Learning for me always involves sweat. Learning is forging those connections-developing those neural circuits! I am excited that through this experience I will learn in new ways by working collaboratively  via new platforms in cyberspace that are grounded by forging personal connections through sharing ideas and questions.  Simultaneously being students and teachers propels us forward as learners. The biggest adjustment for me is feeling at home in such an abstract space (i.e. cyberspace-such as Google docs and wikis). As I sit and think in a comfortable chair in a room with artwork and objects I have collected, I wish my classmates were here with me. It will take me a while to trust this process occurring “out there”  given my wiring to date.  
Upon reflection- I suppose it is no different than writing this and sending my voice out there. Someone might read what I have written and something might resonate with them and some new connections may be born.  As humans we all face our ultimate aloneness and hence we have always sought connections. The connection between emotions and learning makes inherent sense to me because I know I need to feel connected.


Saturday, September 25, 2010

Reflections on the Online Learning Orientation

We do not learn from our experiences; we learn by reflecting
on our experiences.
-John Dewey

I keep this quote in my math lab over my desk. It reminds me to slow down. It reminds me to take the time I need to reflect. As a learner I have to balance my outer experience with my inward response. There is inherent internal tension between the ways I have learned in the past and the roles I have had as a student and the ways I am trying to learn now and the new roles (demands) I will take on as an online student in this cohort. The online medium has presented me with a whole new terrain.
 I have taken a couple online seminars but they did not involve interacting with other students. I am still adjusting to the number of students in this course. I am a “people person.” I talk to strangers in elevators. I am generally outgoing and friendly. I smile. I laugh. I read body language. In cyberspace those little smiley faces just don’t inform me the way face-to-face and tone of voice would. I can learn 25 new names –all attached to new faces in a short time. I have visual strategies and experience doing this. And yet, in this new medium, I am still figuring out how to keep everyone straight in my mind. I am trying to develop new strategies –e.g., he lives in Virginia, she just got married, I had interplay of IM with that person, and she works with children with special needs, but it is more difficult without that face-to-face handshake. The photos help. Reading welcome blurbs gave me “tags” but the sheer number of classmates seems overwhelming. I have to admit, I got bleary-eyed looking at the list connecting our Welcome threads. I work on a laptop- maybe I need a desktop with a big screen and bigger font!
Back to the importance of reflection, thank you for this assignment. I feel as if I am back to my comfort zone in school being asked to reflect or journal. Or maybe I am just interpreting the assignment as journaling because that is something I have always done. At Bank Street we submitted journal entries for every course! Probably we went overboard but I firmly believe- it made the whole experience richer and deeper and more meaningful. In my personal life, I often write to find out what I am really thinking about, as crazy as that sounds. Sometimes I have so many thoughts, so many reactions, so many things going on in my life, taking that time out to write is the only way I slow down and re-center myself.
I found the synchronous session helpful. One classmate talked about how he had realized that he had to be intentional and task-oriented to maximize the time he had to spend on the site. We all are clearly busy with our everyday work. Just one facet of our lives could fill all our time and yet, how many facets and layers do we live in and hold in our hearts? I thought the assignment to make videos helped us create more personal connections and I think that will help us feel more connected as we move forward. Perhaps we should do that again, now as we know how! (I enjoyed learning how to use photo peach and animoto)
With school just starting up, it has been a juggling act to figure out how to actually fit this work in.  The learning curve technically speaking, simply figuring out how to navigate the site was steep. First it was realizing the JHU email site is different from the registrar and billing site. And then realizing the learning platform was yet another address. Alas, I have three new mailboxes and a whole new way of thinking about school. I am establishing new rhythms so that I can accomplish what I need to accomplish for this course and in my work.
Many more people will be going to school online in the future and I am glad to experience first-hand how it can be done. I am looking forward to working as a student in a collaborative group. I am glad to understand that you will be breaking us into smaller groups for projects. I have not worked that way as a student. I have primarily studied and worked independently as a student. After this two-week orientation, I realize that this online course will not only provide me with the academic content I sought but with all these other experiences and layers of learning as well. I am looking forward to getting those new textbooks and delving into them.
This blog will give me the space I need to reflect throughout this learning adventure. To be a successful learner, I have to give myself this space and time.