Friday, October 22, 2010

Calling for New Neural Networks

No matter how sophisticated our neuroimaging techniques are and can become- in terms of viewing brain activity and the firing of neural networks while a person is performing given tasks.....we will most likely still assess that person’s learning by a different means- e.g., performance assessment or another application.  In other words, cognitive scientists and educators will need to continue to work together. It might be that neuroscientists can use imaging to locate specific areas of the brain and/or specific neural networks in action when a person is doing specific tasks but the momentum behind this effort is to obtain an even broader picture. When those neural networks are firing together, what does it mean in terms of what that individual can do and what are the connections or extensions of that learning? How do those firings or those neural networks relate or extend to higher-order thinking? And, even more important, can that individual apply that higher order thinking effectively to a worthy cause? (which takes this discussion beyond neuroscience and education)
It is exciting that certain mental processes have been linked to certain brain structures and we are gaining a better understanding of how people learn. This can help us design more effective instructional techniques. However, it seems what is happening at the cellular level in the brain will only be one piece of the marvel- when it comes to considering a functioning human being. How people learn is only part of the whole: what they experience: how they perceive their experiences: each unique individual has layers of stories as to who he or she is. Ultimately the world is a better place depending on what people do with that learning, their intelligence, attention, talents and genetic endowment in relation to other people, who are just as complex with their own unique “wiring” and experiences.
Cognitive genetics is a new field. Some day we might be able to understand differences between individuals in terms of intelligence and temperament in terms of variations in genes. However, I don’t want to imagine schools performing genetic tests to track students. Instead, I hope that in better understanding the relationship of genes and experience in shaping a students learning potential, schools can find ways to develop effective instructional techniques for all.
We are learning more about what happens in the brain as people look, listen, attend and remember. The best case scenario would be thinking that the more we know about the way the brain works as people learn, the more effective and efficient our teaching could become. However, I don’t think it will ever be that simple.  Humans are too complex. People are always subject to their experiences and we can never isolate one teaching strategy for example and verifiably say- it is what caused “the learning,” because there are so many factors involved in every individual and so many factors that influence learning. Overall health, emotions, psychology, socialization, family upbringing, culture, genetics....(the list goes on and on) all have an impact on learning.
So far our best approach is to think in terms of models, like the Brain-Targeted Teaching model, in order to be sure our school’s are maximizing the environment for learning so that learning can be positive for a wide range of students, because of their inherently wide range of temperaments, genetic endowments, intelligence, and powers of attention and all the other corroborating factors listed above.
Instead of working in isolated fields of study, genetic, cognitive and neuro-scientists, educational psychologists, and teacher researchers need to work together to synthesize their ideas and to ask new questions in order to redesign our schools so that they can be a place for learning for all students. At its best, schools are places for growth and they indeed have been where many have found their “calling” and discovered their passions- which in turn, set them on their life journey. But too many students report that school stifled their growth, their creativity, their very ability to have a vision for their future because it made them lose confidence in themselves and set them on a downward trajectory. This is the worst to face – but we must. And we must do something about it. It will take many great minds with a variety of expertise and special knowledge all firing (working) together.

1 comment:

Sharon D. said...

Hi Merry,
You’re so right we each are so multifaceted. We each are an amalgam of “temperaments, genetic endowments, intelligence, and powers of attention and all the other corroborating factors.”

Yet this process of inquiry into neuroscience and education is valuable because it shines a big light on our individual complexity and reveals the futility of trying to standardize how the "average brain" works and learns.

The BTT Model is so inspiring because it allows for this complexity and provides much opportunity for students to direct their own learning. Other programs that foster this approach are:

Starwars creator George Lucas’s website Edutopia. I am sure you know this website, but for your convenience here it is again:

http://www.edutopia.org/project-based-learning-overview-video

and
Geoffrey & Renate Caine have been promoters of Project Based Learning since the 1980’s! Information about their work is available at:

http://www.cainelearning.com

http://www.learningtolearn.sa.edu.au/Colleagues/pages/default/caine/?reFlag=1

http://www.naturallearninginstitute.org/

Post a Comment